Three strangers share an obsession with true crime and suddenly find themselves wrapped up in one.

Steve Martinas Charles-Haden Savage
Martin Shortas Oliver Putnam
Selena Gomezas Mabel Mora
Amy Ryanas Jan Bellows
Aaron Dominguezas Óscar Torres
Michael Cyril Creightonas Howard Morris
Cara Delevingneas Alice Banks
Quincy Dunn-Bakeras Kev
Adam DeCarloas Guy on the Street
Madeleine Valenciaas Young Mabel Mora
John Hoffman
Ben Smith
Kristin Newman
J. J. Philbin
Kirker Butler
Sas Goldberg
Kim Rosenstock
Thembi Banks
Steve Martin
Siddhartha Khosla