A posse discovers a trio of men they suspect of murder and cow theft and are split between handing them over to the law or lynching them on the spot.

Henry Fondaas Gil Carter
Dana Andrewsas Donald Martin
Mary Beth Hughesas Rose Mapen/Rose Swanson
Anthony Quinnas Juan Martínez/Francisco Morez
William Eytheas Gerald Tetley
Harry Morganas Art Croft
Jane Darwellas Ma Grier
Matt Briggsas Judge Daniel Tyler
Harry Davenportas Arthur Davies
Frank Conroyas Maj. Tetley