Boston is being terrorized by a series of seemingly random murders of women. Based on the true story, the film follows the investigators path through several leads before introducing the Strangler as a character. It is seen almost exclusively from the point of view of the investigators who have very few clues to build a case upon.

Tony Curtisas Albert DeSalvo
Henry Fondaas John S. Bottomly
George Kennedyas Det. Phil DiNatale
Mike Kellinas Julian Soshnick
Hurd Hatfieldas Terence Huntley
Murray Hamiltonas Det. Frank McAfee
Jeff Coreyas John Asgeirsson
Sally Kellermanas Dianne Cluny
William Marshallas Atty. Gen. Edward W. Brooke
George Voskovecas Peter Hurkos