A 17th-century witch returns to wreak havoc in the life of a descendant of the Puritan witch hunter who burned her, but runs afoul of her father when she discovers that her mischief might have found her true love.

Fredric Marchas Jonathan / Nathaniel / Samuel / Wallace Wooley
Veronica Lakeas Jennifer
Robert Benchleyas Dr. Dudley White
Susan Haywardas Estelle Masterson
Cecil Kellawayas Daniel
Elizabeth Pattersonas Margaret
Robert Warwickas J. B. Masterson
Georgia Backusas Older Woman (uncredited)
Charles Batesas Wooley's Son (uncredited)
Brooks Benedictas Country Club Guest (uncredited)
Ted Tetzlaff